![]() ![]() Section 5: OPA Board Subject: No-Goose Grass Msg# 1144126
|
||||||
People often want to remove geese from an area because of the misconception that geese or their droppings are a health hazard. No study, however, links Canada geese to any infectious disease that is transmittable to humans or domestic animals. Additionally, geese do not significantly increase the levels of harmful bacteria in ponds and reservoirs.
For starters: While Canada geese feces can be hazardous to humans, it typically has to be inhaled or ingested to negatively impact a person’s health. This is because many health risks associated with Canada geese feces arise from the parasites and bacteria within them, not the feces themselves. For the average healthy person, it’s generally safe to walk past or lounge nearby these feces. However, not everyone can easily combat these parasites and bacteria, and thus might develop uncomfortable and sometimes life-threatening illnesses. As such, if a person who’s been exposed to geese feces falls ill shortly after, it's best for them to see their health care provider to get appropriate treatment. Geese feces typically contain a number of pathogens which may come into contact with people and pose varying health risks depending on the person. Common parasites within geese feces include cryptosporidium and giardia. Likewise, common bacteria may include methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), Escherichia coli (E. coli), coliform, and campylobacter. These parasites and bacteria might come into contact with humans through direct or indirect contact with geese feces and through consumption of meat from infected animals. That said, direct contact is significantly less likely to introduce these pathogens to people, unless they are directly touching dead geese. However, the elderly, children, people who are immunocompromised, have gastrointestinal (GI) issues, or are pregnant or breastfeeding may be particularly susceptible to health risks posed by these pathogens. As such, it’s safest practice for people to avoid geese feces altogether to minimize their health risks. Of all the pathogens within geese feces, cryptosporidium poses the most serious health hazard since it causes cryptosporidiosis in humans. People with cryptosporidiosis are likely to experience watery stools, dehydration, stomach pain, weight loss, fever, and vomiting. These symptoms typically manifest within a week of infection and may last up to two weeks. Additionally, this infection might become serious if untreated since dehydration may set in, especially for people who can’t easily combat this parasite. As a result, if someone has GI distress for more than a couple of days, they may find it most helpful to check-in with their health care providers. Since cryptosporidium is most commonly spread through water (a place geese like to hang out), many cities and municipalities in the United States have established rigorous water monitoring programs to protect their residents. These efforts were largely inspired by a 1993 outbreak of cryptosporidium in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, which resulted in 400,000 people falling ill and 100 deaths. Yet, despite this epidemic and scientific evidence on the risks posed by cryptosporidium, water monitoring programs remain largely unstandardized across the country; while many areas have implemented programs to prevent future epidemics, others haven’t and therefore remain vulnerable to being parasitic contamination. As such, depending on where you are, your likelihood for being infected by cryptosporidium can vary. Beyond water monitoring programs, some places in the U.S. have chosen to reduce the risk of pathogenic infections by decreasing the number of nearby geese flocks. Tactics are strategically not aggressive as Canada geese are federally protected animals, and killing them or destroying their eggs without a legal permit is a punishable offense. Some tactics include startling the birds with loud noises, removing nesting material if no eggs are present in the nest, and relocating geese by trained animal personnel. With all this said, the next time you’re at the beach, you may wish to advise people to minimize their contact with or completely avoid geese feces. You can specifically suggest that children not place their hands or fingers in their mouths while they’re playing on the beach, and that they wash their hands before eating and after leaving the beach. If you’re still concerned about the amount of feces in the area, you may wish to contact your municipal, county, or state public health department. Through these agencies, you can inquire about any current efforts to deter Canada geese by the beach and clean up existing waste. If you're particularly concerned, you may also want to find other places to spend time outdoors away from the beach, such as parks, hiking trails, or a different beach. |
||||||
|
||||||
For reference, the above message is a reply to a message where: Hi Joe, It was nice meeting you as well. Always nice to have a face with a name. I’m on a national steering committee supported by “In Defense of Animals” called National Goose Protection Coalition. According to our documents, the idea that slaughtered geese will be fed to humans or animals is a myth. Geese eat greenery contaminated with pesticides and insecticides, and meat inspection laws prohibit slaughterhouses with poultry processing licenses from taking wild caught geese. I would be interested to have a discussion with Mike Hooks since no one responded to me in 2018 when I reached out to confirm where the slaughtered geese went. If you would be so kind to send his phone number to me, I will call him and discuss. People often want to remove geese from an area because of the misconception that geese or their droppings are a health hazard. No study, however, links Canada geese to any infectious disease that is transmittable to humans or domestic animals. Additionally, geese do not significantly increase the levels of harmful bacteria in ponds and reservoirs. If you ask Tom Janasek (and I also have a copy of the water tests conducted by ACT in 2018), the bacteria levels in our ponds actually increased after the cull in 2018. A significant amount of dog fecal matter did show up in our recent PCR water tests, as well as human DNA, which caused all the ruckus. Instead, studies show that pollution from human waste and agricultural runoff can expose both geese and humans to bacterial contamination. The best protective measures include addressing poor water circulation, sediment buildup, over-fertilization, and other environmental factors and employing common sense when around potentially contaminated areas. Goose droppings pose little health hazard since they consist of 70% water and 30% grass. If they bake in the sun, they actually turn into little straw like poofs. It is unethical to kill an animal because it poops and we find it inconvenient when there are a lot of non-lethal management practices that can be employed. We must find a way to co-exist with Canada geese and other wildlife. We will always have them in Ocean Pines. If Ocean Pines oils the eggs, puts up a barrier (hopefully attractive) between the land and ponds, geese will feel less safe to propagate and will find other places to molt as well. We can do this. It is a matter of educating the residents and increasing our general tolerance of these animals. Thank you for personally reaching out to me and not bashing me on the forum. I retired here to have a peaceful rest of my life and not to become involved in local politics or the HOA issues. But nothing gets my dander up more than someone abusing children, animals, or the elderly. I stand up for the voiceless and have never gotten over June 29th, 2018 when I woke up to a quiet South Pond from the secretive cull. The round-up was highly controversial and upset many residents. Gassing is also a horrible death for birds with such a large lung capacity. Regards, Sharon |
Calendar |
![]() 6/28/2025 - 9:00 A.M. |
![]() 7/26/2025 - 9:00 A.M. |
![]() 8/9/2025 - 9:00 A.M. |